Irish Government Greenwashes Consistent Emissions Cut Failings

The Irish Government has today approved the purchase of almost €3 million worth of carbon credits from Slovakia as it seeks to meet the EU’s emission target compliance deadline, according to The Journal.

While this is a legal process that is permitted under EU law, and will allow Ireland to meet this week’s deadline, it also allows the Irish Government to cover up their woeful inaction on cutting greenhouse gas emissions in the face of the Climate Crisis.

Find out more about the implications for the Climate Crisis, Irish public health, and the cost of inaction to the taxpayer.

Credits Trading

Ireland had pledged to cut emissions across multiple sectors by 20% compared to 2005 levels, yet data from the Environmental Protection Agency showed that this target was missed by a catastrophically large margin.

In fact, Ireland only managed to cut its emissions by 7% compared to 2005 levels, even despite the impact that the Covid-19 pandemic had on lowering emissions from transport and industry.

This is only just over a third of our targeted cuts!

Despite endless promises and EU-wide legislation, Ireland cut its emissions by just 7% compared to 2005 levels. This is just over a third of the targeted 20%, and constitutes a massive failure by our Government. Credit: Irish Environmental Protection Agency

The utter failure to meet these targets has major implications not only for public health, with air pollution still rampant and resulting in 1,300 premature deaths in Ireland each year, but also confirms the nation as one of the world’s greatest climate laggards.

The consistent failings of the Irish Government to cut emissions at all, let alone in line with the urgent deadlines in place under EU law, makes it considerably more likely that we will blast past 2°C of warming and head towards runaway climate breakdown that will lead to the deaths of millions, the loss of one third of all animal and plant species on Earth by 2070, and the displacement of billions of people by 2050.

As a result of its recidivistic inaction, Ireland must buy its way to compliance by buying credits from countries with lower emissions. But this doesn’t undo the actual harm that Ireland is doing, it just covers it up.

This is the same lie that car companies have been selling for years through emissions pooling – pretending that you can move emissions around from one place to another to hide away from the repercussions just a little longer.

The Covid-19 pandemic only led to minor and short-lived reductions in greenhouse gas emissions in Ireland. The graph above shows not only a consistent failure to cut emissions, but a trend of increasing emissions from 2011 onwards. Credit: EPA

Hiding Their Failures

This isn’t the first time that Ireland has purchased carbon credits.

According to a Dáil Éireann debate in May 2022, Ireland already held 2.9 million international credits, of which 1.4 million were purchased in 2021.

In fact, in 2020 the former Minister for Communications, Climate Action and Environment, Richard Bruton, stated that he believed his Government’s failure to cut emissions could cost the nation as much as €150 million in carbon credits.

The reality is that there is an incentive for Irish politicians to cover up their consistent failure to act in the face of the Climate Crisis. Their declaration of a Climate Emergency in 2019 was nothing more than an empty PR stunt designed to win favour, with little effort or interest in actually acting in accordance with climate science.

By purchasing carbon credits from other nations they can hide their cowardice and keep lying to the people of Ireland that they are acting in their best interests. Failure to comply with EU law would expose their inaction and jeopardise their plush taxpayer-funded jobs.

At this point, it would have been better to have missed the deadline and faced the consequences so that the people of Ireland could confront the Government on their unceasing failures and replace it with a Government that will take the necessary steps to be transparent and cut emissions.

The Earth doesn’t care where the emissions are coming from – only that there are too many, and that delaying action perpetually will worsen the situation exponentially.

Climate Imperialism

Not only is Ireland a major climate laggard, but we also have a disproportionately large impact on global emissions given our relatively small size.

The average person in Ireland has a carbon footprint almost three times larger than the average person on Earth, and 55% higher than the average resident of the EU.

Our bloated agriculture sector and sky-high transport emissions are leading factors in making Ireland a massive greenhouse gas emitter, which is resulting in real-world implications for nations in the Global South.

The map above shows just how much of a climate laggard Ireland is, with an average carbon footprint of 13.3 tonnes of CO2 per capita per year. The graphic also exposes that we are now spending almost as much on carbon credits as we are on overseas development aid. Credit: Central Statistics Office

A minimum of 1.2 billion people are expected to be displaced by the Climate Crisis by 2050, while multiple famines and severe weather events caused directly by the Climate Emergency are causing loss of life around the world this very minute.

Our Government’s failure to cut emissions is an act of Climate Imperialism.

In the same way that the British Empire subjugated the people of Ireland and bent them to its will, so we today are doing the same, irrevocably changing the lives of billions of people to fit our high-carbon lifestyles. Causing death, destruction and ecological desolation in the process.

All this is occurring at a time when our own TDs, and even our Taoiseach, are stoking racist anti-immigration rhetoric, which is spilling over into violence on the streets of Ireland.

Our current refugee policies are based on abusing the human rights of those who are seeking solace here in Ireland, they are racist and they are not fit for purpose. And, like our emissions failings, efforts to replace Direct Provision with a compassionate and humane system are also woefully behind schedule.

Be in no doubt that our Government’s inaction on cutting greenhouse gas emissions is creating a climate refugee crisis that they are to failing to acknowledge, while point-blank refusing to provide care to those who suffer at their hands around the world.

 

What To Read Next

Cowardice, Compassion & Climate Politics

We look at the consistent cowardice of Irish politicians in addressing the Climate Crisi, and the need for greater compassion at home & around the world as the Climate Emergency intensifies

Stop Engaging In Climate Imperialism

We explore what climate imperialism is, why it matters in the face of the Climate Crisis, and why you shouldn’t participate in it

Why Your Carbon Footprint Matters

While the concept of a personal carbon footprint is the creation of Big Oil, we highlight why it still matters in the face of the Climate Crisis